How satisfied are we with our current healthcare system? How satisfied should we be?
In a recent Deloitte report, the American public does not seem to believe the hype that the US has the best healthcare system. From the Hill's Healthcare Blog:
survey found negative attitudes at nearly every level. For example,
despite lawmakers' frequent claims that the U.S. has the best healthcare
system in the world, only 24 percent of Americans view it as even among
the world's best systems."
When you rank 37th in the world,
eventually someone might start paying attention, asking questions and
wondering why the US healthcare system "ain't doing so hot". Usually in
the political arena someone says - "but we have such a unique system,
international comparisons aren't helpful." From NEJM:
the claim by many in the U.S. health policy community that
international comparison is not useful because of the uniqueness of the
United States, the rankings have figured prominently in many arenas. It
is hard to ignore that in 2006, the United States was number 1 in terms
of health care spending per capita but ranked 39th for infant mortality,
43rd for adult female mortality, 42nd for adult male mortality, and
36th for life expectancy. These facts have fueled a question now being
discussed in academic circles, as well as by government and the public:
Why do we spend so much to get so little?"
some ways, it is good that the public is less and less inclined to
believe that our healthcare system is the best. While we do have some of
the best healthcare providers out there, the system in which they have
to operate is broken, expensive and consistently fragmented.
Another telling statistic from the report:
consumers do not have a strong understanding of how their health care
system works. Consistently across the 12 countries surveyed, with the
exception of Portugal (17 percent) and Luxembourg (16 percent), around
one in three consumers felt they understood the system well. Three in
four U.S. consumers (76 percent) feel they do not have a strong
understanding of how the health care system works; this perception has
not changed in recent years (77 percent in 2010, 74 percent in 2009)."
not only are we dissatisfied, we often don't understand how our
healthcare system works.
Will the community
rise up and begin to demand more from their healthcare system? Only time
will tell, but studies like this show that maybe the public is ready to question the healthcare "system".
Collaborative care is no exception when it comes to satisfaction.
the community demanding more "integrated care” from the system? Does
the community see the value and importance of better integrating mental
healthcare into the fabric of healthcare?
Based on the above information, I am beginning to wonder if I should trade in all my degrees for one in marketing.
|Ben Miller is a daily blogger at
his tweets can be followed at @miller7. He is an Assistant Professor
in the Department of Family Medicine at the University of Colorado
Denver School of Medicine. He is the President-Elect of CFHA.|